Report: Local Governments Taxing the Poor With Fees, Surcharges

Discussion in 'Civil Rights & Privacy' started by CATO Police Misconduct, Jul 4, 2012.

  1. From the New York Times:
    In Georgia, three dozen for-profit probation companies operate in hundreds of courts, and there have been similar lawsuits. In one, Randy Miller, 39, an Iraq war veteran who had lost his job, was jailed after failing to make child support payments of $860 a month. In another, Hills McGee, with a monthly income of $243 in veterans benefits, was charged with public drunkenness, assessed $270 by a court and put on probation through a private company. The company added a $15 enrollment fee and $39 in monthly fees. That put his total for a year above $700, which Mr. McGee, 53, struggled to meet before being jailed for failing to pay it all.
    “These companies are bill collectors, but they are given the authority to say to someone that if he doesn’t pay, he is going to jail,” said John B. Long, a lawyer in Augusta, Ga., who is taking the issue to a federal appeals court this fall. “There are things like garbage collection where private companies are O.K. No one’s liberty is affected. The closer you get to locking someone up, the closer you get to a constitutional issue.”
    The issue of using the courts to produce income has caught the attention of the country’s legal establishment. A recent study by the nonpartisan Conference of State Court Administrators, “Courts Are Not Revenue Centers,” said that in traffic violations, “court leaders face the greatest challenge in ensuring that fines, fees and surcharges are not simply an alternate form of taxation.”
    J. Scott Vowell, the presiding judge of Alabama’s 10th Judicial Circuit, said in an interview that his state’s Legislature, like many across the country, was pressuring courts to produce revenue, and that some legislators even believed courts should be financially self-sufficient.
    In a 2010 study, the Brennan Center for Justice at the New York University School of Law examined the fee structure in the 15 states — including California, Florida and Texas — with the largest prison populations. It asserted: “Many states are imposing new and often onerous ‘user fees’ on individuals with criminal convictions. Yet far from being easy money, these fees impose severe — and often hidden — costs on communities, taxpayers and indigent people convicted of crimes. They create new paths to prison for those unable to pay their debts and make it harder to find employment and housing as well as to meet child support obligations.”
    Most of those fees are for felonies and do not involve private probation companies, which have so far been limited to chasing those guilty of misdemeanors. A decade or two ago, many states abandoned pursuing misdemeanor fees because it was time-consuming and costly. Companies like Judicial Correction Services saw an opportunity. They charge public authorities nothing and make their money by adding fees onto the bills of the defendants.
    Stephen B. Bright, president of the Southern Center for Human Rights, who teaches at Yale Law School, said courts were increasingly using fees “for such things as the retirement funds for various court officials, law enforcement functions such as police training and crime laboratories, victim assistance programs and even the court’s computer system.”​
    Report: Local Governments Taxing the Poor With Fees, Surcharges is a post from
    [​IMG] [​IMG]

    Continue reading...
  2. Lisa Simeone

    Lisa Simeone Original Member

    The privatization of America.
  3. nachtnebel

    nachtnebel Original Member

    Aren't debtors' prison unconstitutional?

    From that article:

  4. Lisa Simeone

    Lisa Simeone Original Member

  5. Frank

    Frank Original Member

    Apparently a judge has decided enough is enough.

    Check out what he ordered the mayor and town council to do. Too bad he didn't make them read the Constitution and write a report on it. Then again, as Scott put it, requirements for elected office stop at "breathing".
  6. nachtnebel

    nachtnebel Original Member

    That's pretty cool, thanks for posting this, Frank. Looks like he's tightening his hold around their necks til they tap out.
  7. Frank

    Frank Original Member

    Now we just need a judge in Georgia to take notice.

Share This Page